Monday, April 20, 2009

Is the stadium's design the cause of all these homers?

From AccuWeather.com:
The abundance of homers is raising concerns that the new stadium's design may favor fly balls, which should be alarming to the baseball team that invested $243.5 million on pitching last winter, according to the Daily News.

The wind on Saturday during the Yankees' 22-4 loss against the Cleveland Indians was mostly from the west at 15-20 mph. Given the layout of the stadium, the wind could have had an effect on fly balls in right field. Six home runs were hit by the Indians in the second inning alone.

Although the field dimensions of the new stadium are exactly that of the old stadium, the shell of the new stadium is shaped differently. AccuWeather.com meteorologists also estimate that the angle of the seating in the new stadium could have an effect on wind speed across the field.

The old Yankee stadium had more stacked tiers and a large upper deck, acting like a solid wall in effect, which would cause the wind to swirl more and be less concentrated. The new Yankee stadium's tiers are less stacked, making a less sharp slope from the top of the stadium to the field. This shape could enable winds to blow across the field with less restriction. In addition, the slope of the seating would also lead to a "downslope" effect in the field which, depending on wind direction, would tend to cause air to lift up in the right field. Fly balls going into right field during a gusty west wind would be given more of a lift thus carrying the ball farther out into right field.

If the stadium seating tier shape is indeed the issue, games will only be affected during times with the winds are from a westerly direction and above 10 mph. This typically occurs during the spring and the middle to late fall. The calmer weather during the summer should lead to a smaller number of home runs. In the meantime, the home run derby may continue.
Here's a few illustrations from AccuWeather.com:


Old Yankee Stadium & New Yankee Stadium

Interesting, I think there could be something to this because clearly there are balls are flying out of that place that just shouldn't be home runs. Some of those shots looked like pop ups off the bat.

This is also not the worst news because at least it will only occur at certain points of the year and not all season long. Although middle to late fall is also right around October and playoff time, which certainly won't be good for the Yankees staff, but we'll cross that bridge when we come to it.

17 Comments:

dan said...

hey Greg Im doing a project on MLB Ticket prices... do u mind if I use one of pics that shows all those empty seats in the lower level?... i will probably just use a link.

Greg Cohen said...

No problem Dan, go ahead.

dan said...

thanks

when it comes to the stadium, they have to do something.. we cant have 5+ hrs a game.. its just not good baseball. Is it too late to move back across the street?.. jk

Brian Danuff said...

Wait, I just checked out MLB.com and on the schedule on the left hand side it says:

OAK - NYY PPD (under the red line)

But one of the headlines say you can watch the game at its scheduled time on MLB.TV

Greg Cohen said...

It's a rainout Yankeeboy.

Brian Danuff said...

What? Ahh man!!!!

Unknown said...

Ya know, I have reason to think that the still upstanding old stadium may be affecting the winds in the new stadium.

When you drive by on the Deegan, the old stadium stands out in front of the new one, so wind gets pushed from the front side of the new stadium and then creeps over the wall of the new one, further pushed over and into right field because of the new slope of the concourses... Im no physicist... but it sortof makes sense considering the winds that fly over the river from the heights and down towards that area of the Bronx.

Maybe it will calm down once that building gets demo'd. Its possible...

Brian Danuff said...

Are you absoultely, postiviely sure that the game is rained out?

Greg Cohen said...

That's possible Derek. I want to see how stadium plays during the summer months when supposedly the wind isn't going to be an issue.

Greg Cohen said...

Unless MLB.com and Yankees.com are lying, yes, the game has been rained out.

Bostowned said...

Yankeeboy said exactly what I was going to say. Once old Yankee Stadium comes down (tear) the dynamics of the wind will be altered.

That or the Yanks start looking into signing a lot of strike out pitchers. lol.

Anonymous said...

most of the hr's came from wang and the yankees relief. maybe wind helps the ball carry out. sabathia, chamberlain and burnett only gave up about 4 hr's.

Capone said...

Imagine how far the ball will go when the weather gets warm...scary

Will said...

the news is silly to suggest that a hitters park would hurt the yankee investment in pitching - if anything you need even better pitching in a hitters park. in the mets field I could pitch and it would still be hard to hit home runs.

Anonymous said...

according to this diagram and article the fences are exactly the same as the old stadium at the markers, but not in between especially in right where the fence curved in the old stadium and is now a straight line in the new stadium.

http://waswatching.com/2009/04/19/is-the-new-yankee-stadium-a-homer-haven/

Mike B. said...

I went to the games Friday and Sunday (thank heavens they won after I flew up from Nashville), and a few guys told me how 1) the old stadium that's still standing might very well have something to do with it; and 2) those "slots" in the wall right behind the last row of grandstand seats might have something to do with it, too.

I'll add one more thing: as I sat in the RCF bleachers on Friday I noticed more of a breeze than I ever noticed in the RCF bleachers in the old place. Hmmm....

I love the new place, but I'll look for the appropriate thread from the last few days and post there.

Mike

Unknown said...

Bostowned that was me not yankeeboy.. haha.

Much like my Igawa with shades theory from a year back.... Im stickin with this one..

The old building is affecting that wind. Big time.