Utility Infielders
Willy Aybar
Decent amount of pop, strong history against LHP, adequate at 1B, 2B, and 3BChristian Guzman
High-contact approach, middling power, switch-hitter (slightly better against LHP), adequate at 2B and SSJerry Hairston
High-contact approach, middling power, no platoon splits, fine base-runner, adequate at 2B and SS, solid outfielder as wellOutfielders
Scott Hairston
Mashes LHP, decent base-runner, solid defensive outfielderReed Johnson
Mashes LHP, sort of injury prone, solid corner outfielder, middling in centerAndruw Jones
Mashes LHP, solid corner outfielder, subpar in centerGabe Kapler
Very good against LHP, solid corner outfielder, subpar in centerManny Ramirez
Limited platoon splits in recent years, probably shouldn't play much outfield (though right could be easier in Yankee Stadium)Marcus Thames
Mashes LHP, overachieved a bit last season, probably shouldn't play much outfieldStarting Pitchers
Justin Duchscherer
Limited to five (very good) starts over the past two seasons, decent groundball rateJeff Francis
Lefty, injury prone (shoulder issues), good groundball rates, good walk ratesFreddy Garcia
Injury prone, league-average innings eaterKevin Millwood
League-average innings eater, trending downBrad Penny
Injury prone, good groundball rates, good walk ratesAndy Pettitte
Baby come backBrandon Webb
Hasn't pitched in nearly two years, shoulder issues - formerly elite, with very good groundball, strikeout, and walk ratesRelievers
Grant Balfour
Type A free agent (draft pick), great strikeout rates, improved control, flyball pitcherTodd Coffey
Underrated, very good groundball rates, good walk and strikeout ratesOctavio Dotel
Great strikeout rates, up and down control, flyball pitcherKevin Gregg
Very good strikeout rates, middling control, inconsisent groundball ratesBob Howry
Did his best work with Larry Rothschild, flyball pitcher, good strikeout and walk ratesChad Qualls
Very good groundball rate, good strikeout and walk ratesJon Rauch
Good strikeout and walk rates, flyball pitcherTakashi Saito
Great strikeout rates, very good control, neutral groundball/flyball splitsRafael Soriano
Type A, elite relieverWhile Cashman has certainly missed out on a fair share of quality players, there are still some fine options available. Signing the Brothers Hairston and Todd Coffey - reasonable targest, in my mind, would solidify the bench and bullpen quite a bit. If they're feeling frisky, perhaps the Yankees could roll the dice on Rafael Soriano (they do have a compensation round pick, after all).